. Macaroni n' Cheese : A classic baked elbow macaroni with a creamy cheese blend. Mashed Potatoes : Available with either Turkey Gravy (holiday only), Sawmill Gravy (peppery pork flavors), or Brown Gravy . Green Beans : Slow-simmered with pork seasoning for a traditional Southern profile. Fried Apples : Sliced and seasoned with cinnamon, these serve as a side or a dessert topper. Whole Baby Carrots : Cooked with margarine and brown sugar for a hint of sweetness. PureWow +1 3. Breads & Accompaniments No Thanksgiving meal is complete without their signature breads, which are included in all Heat & Serve Feast options: Norwich Bulletin Buttermilk Biscuits : Hand-rolled and served with butter. Cornbread Muffins : Fluffy with a buttery crumb, available in standard and holiday packages. Sweet Yeast Rolls : Often provided specifically in the holiday catering bundles. PureWow +1 Summary of Top Choices by Category Category Top Choice Description Crowd Favorite Hashbrown Casserole The most iconic and ordered side. Holiday Essential Sweet Potato Casserole Features the signature pecan topping. Kid-Friendly Macaroni n' Cheese Consistently tender pasta and cheesy sauce. "Healthier" Opt. Steamed Broccoli Low-calorie option with simple savory seasoning. Ordering Tips Pre-Ordering
This is a dessert disguised as a side. Mashed sweet potatoes topped with a pecan streusel and—wait for it—melted marshmallows. It is outrageously sweet. If you have kids at the table, order double. cracker barrel sides for thanksgiving
You can walk in or order online for pickup on Thanksgiving Day (or the days leading up to it) to buy sides individually. Green Beans : Slow-simmered with pork seasoning for