This makes him the perfect foil to Peter Kavinsky. Peter pushes Lara Jean out of her comfort zone and into the spotlight. Josh, conversely, is content to sit in the quiet with her. With Josh, there are no risks, but there is deep understanding. He represents a love that is easy, familiar, and safe. And while "safe" doesn't always make for the most cinematic romance, it is a vital part of Lara Jean’s coming-of-age journey.
The resolution of Josh’s story is bittersweet. He accepts that Margot has moved on, and he accepts that Lara Jean’s heart belongs to someone else. But he isn't left alone in the cold. He retains his status as an honorary Covey. He remains the boy who will always help shovel the snow, who will always be there for Kitty, and who will always be a welcome guest at the house. josh to all the boys
He is the archetype of "soft masculinity" in YA literature. He is intellectual, artistic, gentle, and respectful. He doesn't play sports to conquer; he lives a life of the mind. He is the kind of boy who brings soup when you’re sick and remembers your favorite flavor of tea. In a genre often dominated by aggressive masculinity, Josh’s quiet, soft-spoken nature was a breath of fresh air. This makes him the perfect foil to Peter Kavinsky
Character Analysis: Josh Sanderson in To All the Boys I've Loved Before With Josh, there are no risks, but there
He may not have been the one Lara Jean chose, but he was the one who helped her understand what she was choosing. And for that, Josh Sanderson remains one of the most beloved, underrated, and vital characters in modern YA romance.
One of the most appealing aspects of Josh is his inner life. He is an artist, a sketcher, and a thinker. While Peter K is defined by his social status and lacrosse, Josh is defined by his solitude and his creativity.